Skip to content

SEC-007: The tool list does not change between connections or after a call

Severity Applies to Spec section
error modern era, stdio, http 2026-07-28/server/tools#capabilities

Lists the tools, calls one tool that may be called (with the smallest valid arguments), lists them again, then lists them on a second connection. The set of tools MUST NOT vary per connection or as a side effect of other requests on the connection. A tool whose definition changes after it has been approved (a "rug pull") is how a malicious server slips past a user's review. Definitions are compared in full, ignoring _meta and order (order is CONF-012). 2026-07-28 only: initialize-era sessions were stateful. Runs once per server.

From the command line: mcpprobe checks explain SEC-007. To leave it out of a run, add "SEC-007" to [checks] disable in mcpprobe.toml; to change how much it counts, use severity_overrides.